I Asked the Lord That I Might Grow

I Asked the Lord That I Might Grow is a deeply searching hymn written by John Newton and first published in 1779 in Olney Hymns, the influential collection he prepared with William Cowper. Newton, best known for “Amazing Grace,” was a former slave trader turned Anglican pastor whose hymns often reflect his own painful yet sanctifying spiritual journey. This hymn stands as one of the clearest examples of his pastoral realism and experiential theology.

The hymn is structured around a prayer and God’s unexpected answer to it. Newton begins with a sincere desire for spiritual growth, holiness, and freedom from sin. The request itself is biblical and commendable, echoing passages such as James 1:2-4, where trials are shown to produce patience and maturity. However, as the hymn unfolds, Newton shows that God’s method of answering such prayers often contradicts human expectations. Rather than immediate comfort or visible progress, the believer encounters trials, inward struggles, and a painful exposure of pride and self-reliance.

This tension reflects the biblical teaching of Romans 5:3-5, where tribulation produces perseverance and hope, and Hebrews 12:5-11, which presents God’s discipline as a mark of loving sonship. Newton portrays God as a wise Father who is more concerned with true holiness than temporary ease. The trials described in the hymn are not signs of divine displeasure but instruments of grace, designed to drive the believer away from self-confidence and toward complete dependence on Christ.

A key theological emphasis of the hymn is the destruction of spiritual pride. Newton makes clear that growth in grace often involves the painful removal of false supports. This theme aligns closely with 2 Corinthians 12:7-10, where Paul learns that Christ’s strength is made perfect in weakness. By allowing the believer to feel their helplessness, God teaches them to rest fully in His sufficiency.

I Asked the Lord That I Might Grow has endured because of its honesty. It gives language to the confusion many believers experience when sincere prayers seem to lead to hardship rather than relief. Newton reassures the singer that such experiences are not wasted or accidental. Instead, they are evidence of God’s faithful work, answering prayer in a deeper and wiser way than the believer first imagined. The hymn remains a valuable corrective to shallow views of spiritual growth and a comforting guide for Christians walking through seasons of testing, reminding them that the Lord is accomplishing His good purpose even through painful means.