Tell Me the Old, Old Story

“Tell Me the Old, Old Story” is a beloved 19th-century hymn that tenderly appeals for the retelling of the gospel message—the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. Written by Arabella Catherine Hankey in 1866, the hymn is part of a longer poem titled The Old, Old Story of Jesus and His Love, which she wrote during a lengthy illness. Its heartfelt words reflect a deep yearning for the comforting truth of salvation, repeatedly asking the listener to share the message in a gentle and loving tone. The musical setting composed by William H. Doane in 1867 helped solidify the hymn’s popularity and emotional resonance.

The hymn’s refrain, “Tell me the old, old story of Jesus and His love,” captures its central plea to never grow weary of hearing about God’s redemptive work. Hankey’s verses emphasize the need to hear this gospel message not just once, but again and again. She points to the tendency of the human heart to forget, to become distracted by worldly things, and to drift from the joy and peace found in Christ. By continually hearing the “old, old story,” believers are reminded of the truth that sustains their faith and hope.

Hankey’s writing is pastoral and intimate. She imagines herself as one who is weak and forgetful, asking to be told the gospel gently, “slowly,” and “often,” as one might speak to a weary or suffering soul. Her choice of words conveys humility and deep spiritual need. It reflects the mindset of someone who clings to the gospel not only for salvation but also for daily strength. The hymn becomes a prayer for all who find themselves burdened or distant from God to return to the simple, powerful truth of Christ’s love.

William H. Doane’s tune matches the spirit of the lyrics beautifully. With a tender and flowing melody, it underscores the hymn’s reflective nature. The pairing of Hankey’s poetry and Doane’s music created a hymn that quickly gained favor among evangelicals in both Britain and America. It was often sung during revival meetings, Sunday schools, and personal devotional settings. Its emotional appeal, grounded in biblical truth, has made it enduringly popular.

“Tell Me the Old, Old Story” reminds Christians that the message of Jesus never grows old. It is always relevant, always life-giving, and always needed. Whether for the unbeliever hearing it for the first time or the seasoned saint who needs to be refreshed in heart, the hymn affirms the power of the gospel to speak to every condition of the soul. It is a timeless call to return to the foundation of faith, Jesus and His love.